You are herecontent / Marijuana, a Guide to Healthcare Mandates

Marijuana, a Guide to Healthcare Mandates

By Michael Boldin

Now that Heath Care legislation has passed, the obvious question for opponents is this: Now What? My answer is best summed up with just one word:


No, I don’t mean that you should go out and smoke away your anger and frustration. Instead, you should feel empowered. The best way to explain this is by telling the story of a disabled mother from Northern California.


Angel Raich has been permanently disabled since 1995. She has an inoperable brain tumor, a seizure disorder and other serious medical conditions. In 1997, her doctor felt that marijuana would be an effective medication.

Angel used homegrown marijuana, and she and her physician claim that it’s helped significantly. You may not agree with Angel’s choice, but it’s one made in accordance with California state law, which allows for such use. The federal government, however, has not shown much respect for state laws in recent decades, and chose to take action. After DEA agents seized and destroyed all six of her marijuana plants, she sued to stop them from doing so again.

The suit went all the way to the Supreme Court, and in Gonzales v Raich, Angel lost. The 2005 ruling made clear that the federal government did not recognize state laws authorizing the use of marijuana – in any situation.


The court ruled that control over a plant grown and consumed on one’s own property was authorized under the “Interstate Commerce Clause” of the Constitution. Article I, Section 8, Clause 3 of the Constitution empowers Congress to “regulate…commerce among the several states.” It has never been amended.

Like any legal document, if the words of the Constitution mean today what they meant at the moment it was signed, we must understand just what those words meant at the time of its ratification.

There’s been a lot of scholarly research on this clause, especially the word “commerce” itself. Without getting into the long details of it all, it means this: Congress is authorized to make uniform national rules on the trade and exchange of goods (and related activities like their transportation) that cross state borders. On top of it, the word “regulate” meant to “make regular” – that is, to specify how these transactions may be conducted. Regulate did not mean ban, prohibit, or mandate. These words have different meanings.

With this in mind, the Supreme Court, which is not a set of nine infallible gods, ruled incorrectly. But rule, they did. Thus, all three federal branches agreed that State-level laws allowing marijuana were a no-go. In his dissent, Justice Clarence Thomas gave a stark warning:

“If the Federal Government can regulate growing a half-dozen cannabis plants for personal consumption…then Congress’ Article I powers…have no meaningful limits. Whether Congress aims at the possession of drugs, guns, or any number of other items, it may continue to appropria[te] state police powers under the guise of regulating commerce.”


Even though she lost the case, Angel indicated she’d continue to use marijuana. At the time of the ruling, there were 10 states that had such laws. Not one of them has been repealed. Since then, another 4 states have passed similar laws, and many others are considering them, including South Dakota, Kansas, and New Hampshire.

Today, over half a million people are registered users of medical marijuana, and estimates say that millions more use the plant without registration. What’s been the result? The federal government will occasionally arrest some high-profile users, but taken in the perspective of the multitudes consuming the plant, the threat is quite low.

And, in mid-2009, recognizing a need for “efficient and rational use of its limited investigative and prosecutorial resources,” the Justice Department announced that it would back off the prosecution of medical marijuana patients even further.


You might be asking, “How does this apply to healthcare mandates?” Well, the answer is pretty simple. When enough states pass laws defying federal laws, and enough people actively defy them too, D.C. simply doesn’t have the manpower to arrest and prosecute all of us.

This kind of activism – while it clearly carries personal risk – should be a real blueprint for people that have been consistently unable to find constitutional relief in Congress, the Executive, or the Courts.

Marijuana users: Love ‘em or hate ‘em, but show some respect for them, as many have suffered greatly for doing what they believe is right. People who believe strongly about other issues, like healthcare mandates, would do well to learn from them.

What should be done about federal control over health care? The same thing that should be done for every unconstitutional federal law, regulation, or mandate – Nullify Now!

Michael Boldin [send him email] is the founder of the Tenth Amendment Center, which can be found online at

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I studied this topic in pharmacology, and our text books showed many figures coming to the conclusion that the money spent on the war on drugs far exceeds the total cost of all illicit drugs combined at street value. This tells any dummy that this is a profitable business for enforcement, jails, courts, attorneys. Furthermore, companies have lobbied to prevent this material from becoming a salable item which would cause other commodities such as cotton to suffer when competing in the open market. This same substance was used to single out black people, and give the government cause to unfairly arrest many people. There were scare commercials on television back in the same era of time showing that if you smoke it, you would be so crazy that you would just jump out the window from an elevated building (actually seen this commercial played).

The truth like most other things feed to us by the media, and government; the truth is that it is harmless, not a gate way drug, less potent than alcohol, would be used less if legalized, less crime if legalized, an untapped source for it's fiber for clothes, oil from the seeds are very beneficial, better than any pharma anxiety medication, people have been self medicating for thousands of years, curtails cancer, wonderful for nausea, prevents testicular cancer, and makes a cheap stereo sound great. Look at the facts, then look at what our wonderful trusting government media has to say. I think I will choose using the facts; seen enough of the lies told by the other guy.

Our brains make their own marijuana: We're all pot heads deep inside
Marijuana Could Be a Gusher of Cash If We Treated It Like a Crop, Not a Crime | DrugReporter | AlterNet
Marijuana ingredients show promise in battling superbugs
Marijuana Has Anti-Inflammatory That Won't Get You High
2,700-year-old marijuana stash found // Current
Marijuana Is Real Medicine | DrugReporter | AlterNet
Argentina Legalizes Personal Marijuana Use | | the narcosphere
AlterNet: DrugReporter: Marijuana Gains Wonder Drug Status
AlterNet: DrugReporter: New Study Shows Medical Value of Marijuana
U.S. Is Sued Over Position on Marijuana - New York Times
AlterNet: DrugReporter: The Top Ten Reasons Marijuana Should Be Legal
The body's own 'marijuana' is good for the skin
Developing Brains: Alcohol Worse than Marijuana
Voters Say Yes to Marijuana in Massachusetts and Michigan | DrugReporter | AlterNet
GRITtv with Laura Flanders » Legalizing Marijuana, Dr. Gabor Mate, and Ukraine
More States Embrace Marijuana Decriminalization |
Student suspended after voicing marijuana opinion
DrugReporter: Why Smoking Marijuana Doesn't Make You a Junkie
AlterNet: DrugReporter: New Studies Destroy the Last Objection to Medical Marijuana
marijuana can be good for the aging brain by reducing inflammation there and possibly even stimulating the formation of new brain cells
Why Legalizing Marijuana Makes Sense |
Marijuana helps in battle against cancer: study
Democracy Now! | Citing Failed War on Drugs, Former Seattle Police Chief Calls for Legalization of Marijuana and All Drugs
Medical marijuana user who was denied liver transplant dies
Scientific studies indicate that marijuana can halt the spread of numerous cancer cells
Hawaiian Police, DEA Intend to Ignore County Pot Referendum, Police say county initiative making personal marijuana use in private "the lowest law enforcement priority", which passed overwhelmingly last week, will have no impact on law enforcement practice. - Don't Tase Me, Bro!
t r u t h o u t | California Lawmaker Introduces Legislation to Legalize Marijuana
t r u t h o u t | A Marijuana Tax as the Next New Revenue Stream?
Marijuana rivals mainstream drugs for HIV/AIDS symptoms
Lawmakers Call For An End To Federal Marijuana Prosecutions | NORML Blog
Raw Story » Obama’s drug czar: Marijuana ‘has no medical benefit’
t r u t h o u t | Attorney General Signals Shift in Marijuana Policy
The recession is spotlighting the rationale for decriminalizing marijuana
A one-hour program devoted to the pot industry is one long propaganda project for the ONDCP.
Former Surgeon General: Mainstream Medicine Has Endorsed Medical Marijuana | DrugReporter | AlterNet

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.


Support This Site


Get free books and gear when you become a supporter.



Speaking Truth to Empire


Families United


Ray McGovern


Julie Varughese


Financial supporters of this site can choose to be listed here.



Ca-Dress Long Prom Dresses Canada
Ca Dress Long Prom Dresses on

Buy Books

Get Gear

The log-in box below is only for bloggers. Nobody else will be able to log in because we have not figured out how to stop voluminous spam ruining the site. If you would like us to have the resources to figure that out please donate. If you would like to receive occasional emails please sign up. If you would like to be a blogger here please send your resume.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.