You are herecontent / Feingold Leads Way on Iraq War

Feingold Leads Way on Iraq War

Published on Saturday, October 8, 2005 by the Boston Globe
By Robert Kuttner

President Bush, faced with plummeting support for the war in Iraq, keeps turning to an old standby. In another high-profile speech on Thursday, Bush warned Americans to be terrified of terror, and tried once again to tie Iraq to Al Qaeda and the attacks of 9/11.

The public isn't buying it. A large majority -- 64 to 32 in CBS polls -- opposes Bush's conduct of the war.

Yet the opposition party has been mostly missing in action. Democratic pollsters and political advisers seem to believe that with Bush failing as a war president Democrats should stay out of the way and let him sink.

There is an obsessive worry that Democrats, above all, cannot risk looking weak on defense. If the war keeps going badly and Democrats are seen as opposing it, one strategist told me, they risk getting the blame.

Senior foreign policy Democrats, such as Senators Joseph Biden, John Kerry, and Hillary Clinton, have been willing to criticize Bush's decision to take the country to war on false pretenses, as well as his conduct of the war. But they have not offered a serious discussion of how to get us out.

This mentality is the opposite of leadership. The failure of the opposition party to offer a coherent alternative is one reason why support for the Democrats has not been rising as support for Bush sinks. It is why Democrats have become the butt of Jay Leno jokes as not standing for anything.

One Democrat who has offered another course -- and he must be feeling very lonely -- is Senator Russ Feingold of Wisconsin. He has urged the United States to make a commitment to get all combat troops out of Iraq by the end of 2006. As Feingold says, we need a coherent alternative to either ''stay the course" or ''cut and run." That alternative is phased withdrawal.

Feingold told a Los Angeles audience in late August: ''The president and others say that if we leave, it will just be chaos in Iraq. Well, right now when you come to Iraq, you can't even drive from the airport to the Green Zone" Even inside the supposedly secure Green Zone, Feingold recounted, he was given a helmet and flak jacket.

He added: ''The president says if we leave Iraq on some kind of a timetable, our enemies will know that we are weak. I would say that without a plan to finish, our enemies will know that we have fallen into a trap." Feingold further observed that by calling for a timetable for withdrawal, he had broken what had become a disabling ''taboo."

Critics of the war should be seriously exploring how a phased withdrawal would actually work. If the United States agreed to pull out, what role might NATO and the UN play? What could be expected of other states in the region?

Among many Democratic policy intellectuals unwilling to embrace a timetable for full withdrawal, the second-best is seen as a large reduction of troop levels. The idea is to pull back troops from forward positions where they are exposed to attack, and keep a smaller force garrisoned in Baghdad and other bases.

In principle, this is clever politics -- some troops could come home, and casualties might be reduced. The problem is that the countryside would essentially be ceded to insurgents, who would loudly proclaim their victory over the Great Satan. Iraq would actually be pushed closer to civil war. There would be just enough American troops to continue to be a lightning rod for armed insurgency, but far too few to pacify the place. A full withdrawal would make much more sense.

The dithering Democrats may find that public opinion has passed them by. In the most recent CBS news poll, American adults, by a large margin of 59 to 36, want the United States out of Iraq as soon as possible, even if the country is not stabilized. Among Democrats, the margin rises to 73 to 24, or 3 to 1.

Feingold is no radical. He gets elected in a swing state as a man of integrity and independence. He teamed up with Republican John McCain on campaign finance reform. He voted in favor of John Roberts for chief justice.

If the war is still going on in 2008, an antiwar candidate such as Feingold would be an odds-on favorite to win the Democratic presidential nomination over bigger names disabled by their own fatal caution.

Robert Kuttner, co-editor of The American Prospect, can be reached at His column appears regularly in the Globe.


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

A few weeks ago I posted a suggestion that the United States should seek a cease fire coupled with cooperation of the United Nations and Pan-Arab countries to come in and police Iraq. The above-post serves as a better reasoned version of the same concept. I never professed to be a diplomat but I do think the concept makes a great deal of sense. Who knows, maybe a unilateral gesture by the USA may defuse the ingrained hatred and distrust that our troops deal with while the architects of that hatred and distrust are safely tucked away in their ivory towers in Washington and elsewhere.

As for the claim that Iraq would be reduced to chaos if the USA "cut and run", can someone on the right explain to me how what Iraq is now represents any sort of "order"? I didn't think so.

Taking over from Bush would be like assuming command of the Titanic AFTER it hit the iceberg. The War in Iraq, however, is only the cherry on the whip cream of bad American Foreign Policy. Simple getting us out of this low point of Gunboat Diplomacy would not fundamentally change anything. The "War on Terror" would still be going with no end in sight. You can't change one dirty sock when you're filthy and come out clean.

Who is going to give America a very cold shower and admit to overthrowing the government of Iran, installing a dictator and stealing their oil. What about supporting Saddam knowing he gased his own people and started a murderous war against Iran. What about giving him a nod and a wink before he invaded Kuwait then double crossing him. What about maintaining sanctions that led to the deaths of thousands of Iraqies. Now the War in Iraq insures that the War on Terrorism goes on in perpituity. Convincing Americans that we have brought these ills upon ourselves would be difficult enough. The hard part, however, would be stepping on some very big toes that have a vested interest in the Defense Mentality. You know, what that flaming liberal Eisenhower called the Military-Industrial Complex. There's the rub.

"Toolkit For Stopping A War" is an excellent way to keep on giving and sending the message AFTER the Sept. 24th DC Peace Rally too. Just slip a flyer in your tithing envelope every Sunday (or synagogue or mosque on day of worship, etc) :

This PDA flyer is particularly good and essential , as it mentions and explains the PNAC (Project for a New American Century). It is two pages , so when you copy it , it will need to be copied to single back-to-back sheets. This informative flyer is also great for getting the word out by slipping it into your bill payments /mortgage payment envelopes before mailing them :

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Speaking Events



August 2-6: Peace and Democracy Conference at Democracy Convention in Minneapolis, Minn.


September 22-24: No War 2017 at American University in Washington, D.C.


October 28: Peace and Justice Studies Association Conference

Find more events here.


Support This Site


Get free books and gear when you become a supporter.



Speaking Truth to Empire


Families United


Ray McGovern


Julie Varughese


Financial supporters of this site can choose to be listed here.



Ca-Dress Long Prom Dresses Canada
Ca Dress Long Prom Dresses on

Buy Books

Get Gear

The log-in box below is only for bloggers. Nobody else will be able to log in because we have not figured out how to stop voluminous spam ruining the site. If you would like us to have the resources to figure that out please donate. If you would like to receive occasional emails please sign up. If you would like to be a blogger here please send your resume.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.