You are hereForums / ADS Forums / Impeachment Discussion / Faxed response to John Conyers' five reasons for refusing to impeach

Faxed response to John Conyers' five reasons for refusing to impeach


I had just finished sending this fax to Conyers, and copying my rep and senators, when I logged on here to see that that Dennis Kucinich was live on C-SPAN introducing the articles against Bush. Gotta love the timing! Here's to you, DK! - jp

06-09-08

CONGRESSMAN CONYERS:

STOP ENABLING WAR CRIMINALS! HONOR YOUR OATH! START IMPEACHMENT HEARINGS NOW!

You had a meeting with Code Pink on June 5th, 2008, during which you laid out five reasons why you say impeachment is not possible, challenged them to refute your arguments, and finally declared that they had not directly addressed or effectively disproved all your points.

Here are your stated reasons, each of which I will address directly:

1. The majority does not want impeachment. (While the majority of people in this country dislike, hate and/or are just waiting out the last days of this Administration, they do NOT want impeachment.)

In 2006, the majority of voters in this country, including many who are not Democrats, voted to give your party a majority in Congress, with the unequivocal mandate of getting us out of Iraq and holding the Bush administration accountable for lying to us and Congress. This fact alone suggests that you are quite wrong in this assessment. Additionally: The approval rating for the 110th Congress is even lower than that of the Bush administration, because this Congress has so far failed to honor our will. There are also polls indicating that a clear majority wants Cheney impeached, while impeachment for Bush runs about 50%. But let’s just say for the sake of your argument that the numbers revealed a slight majority in favor of not impeaching. Your argument ignores the view and tramples the rights of the minority, which is unacceptable in a representative republic (you know, like the one we’re supposed to have here in America). You are playing disgusting partisan politics while the integrity of our Constitution and system of government hang in the balance. As someone who has been in Congress for forty years, you should certainly know better. Honoring your oath of office is not contingent upon whether or not the majority supports impeachment. You have overwhelming evidence. You are duty and honor bound to act.

2. The corporate media. (They will slay us. If we aren’t successful in our impeachment effort they will say we didn’t have the evidence to back-up the charges.)

If you hold impeachment hearings, the corporate media will be forced to cover them. America and the world will see the evidence as it is put into the Congressional record. And if the final vote fails for partisan political reasons, the world will know that claims of the evidence not being there are lies. More importantly, you know right now that such a claim would be a lie, because you have documented the evidence yourself. To not act because you’re worried about what a complicit corporate media would say is yet another insult to the Constitution and your promise to honor it.

3. No time. (Congress is scheduled to adjourn Sept. 26, and the process would be long and involved.)

The Constitution you swore to support and defend does not set time constraints for impeachment, outside of which honoring your oath is optional. You could certainly choose to continue the disgusting politics and make the process “long and involved,” but there is no reason to. Bush and Cheney could actually be impeached in a single day for crimes against our Constitution that they have publicly confessed to (torture, warrantless spying). You would simply need to put the evidence into the record and have a vote.

4. No votes. (We do not have enough votes in Congress to be successful.)

Another straw-man argument. How can you expect to have any votes in favor of impeachment until you have conducted hearings and placed the evidence into the record? A criminal prosecutor would certainly not expect a jury to vote for conviction before showing them the evidence. Likewise, no rational person would expect Congress to vote for impeachment before the evidence has been documented during hearings.

5. Election defeat (If Obama lost the election because of an impeachment effort, it would be devastating and I wouldn’t want that on my conscience).

Are you actually suggesting that failing to bring accountability for the Bush administration lies that have (so far) led to more than 4,000 dead American soldiers, more than one million dead innocent Iraqi civilians, five million Iraqi refugees, the destruction of their country, tremendous economic unrest here at home, and the systematic neoconservative dismantling of our Constitution bothers you less than the thought of a Democrat losing an election?

The implication that a failed impeachment effort would guarantee an Obama election loss runs contrary to the entire history of impeachment. Without exception, the party bringing impeachment charges has been successful in subsequent elections. Republicans did lose a few seats after the Senate voted to acquit Clinton after he was impeached, but they retained control of Congress.

Finally: Your general claim that impeachment is not possible is not a valid excuse for refusing to commence with impeachment hearings, and you, of all people, should know it. The book that you wrote, “Constitution in Crisis,” clearly demonstrates that you know the evidence of impeachable offenses committed by the Bush administration perhaps better than anybody in Washington. The fact that you would go to such lengths to document this evidence, only to turn your back on America and refuse to act on it after becoming House Judiciary Chairman, suggests that you have made some sort of illicit compromise.

Stop insulting our intelligence by feigning fear of political retribution for doing the job the people expect of you. You have taken the oath of office 21 times, Mr. Conyers. You need to honor it. If you wish to prove that you have not sold out your country and are indeed still worthy of the peoples’ trust, you will immediately commence impeachment hearings with the goal of bringing true accountability for the crimes of the Bush administration.

UNFILTERED VIDEO COMMENTARY.

DEMAND IMPEACHMENT HEARINGS NOW:
johnconyersjr@gmail.com / john.conyers@mail.house.gov
Conyers phone: 202-225-5126 / Conyers fax: 202-225-0072

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

esp. #5 about the havoc caused in Iraq. Plus the occupation abuses our troops, degrades military readiness, and endangers national security by diverting precious resources from real clear and present dangers like Al Qaeda in Afghanistan/Pakistan and natural disasters like Hurricane Katrina.

Republicans not only "retained control of Congress" but also gained the Presidency after the Clinton impeachment because the voters' negative impressions of the Clinton White House hurt Al Gore [to the point where Gore distanced himself from Clinton and, in effect, failed to benefit from the advantages of having an incumbent President support a candidate].
Impeach today and McCain's election prospects will be damaged by voters' negative feelings towards an President Bush. McCain may even be forced to reject Bush's endorsement and offer to raise campaign cash as well as distance himself from Karl Rove who currently is a McCain informal advisor.

Finally, Your general claim that impeachment is not possible is not a valid excuse for refusing to commence with impeachment hearings, and you, of all people, should know it.
****************************************************************

John...you just can't be a liberal democrat...you state the facts too clearly and make too much sense all the time....LOL

TP

The political party I belong to is the entire body politic of the United States of America and our Constitution that I support without bias which neither states or implies any allegiance with any other socalled organized political party.

I consider myself an American first and foremost, always placing the good of my country before any political objectives. I have always been registered independent and I always will be.

Thanks for the kind words...
JP

UNFILTERED VIDEO COMMENTARY.

DEMAND IMPEACHMENT HEARINGS NOW:
johnconyersjr@gmail.com / john.conyers@mail.house.gov
Conyers phone: 202-225-5126 / Conyers fax: 202-225-0072

Just to quibble a bit..................

Personally I consider myself to be a NATIVE BORN citizen of the United States of "America" because just saying I'm an American today is painting myself or any other U S Citizen with a too broad a brush in my humble opinion. Our forefathers may have stolen this land but I wasn't any part of it and don't feel a bit responsible for defending the act when I volunteered for duty to defend the nation to ANYBODY. Neither am I, one of millions that serveed, am a hero for serving my nation.

Now that may be a quibble...but one I have no need to try and justify or otherwise explain.

TP

The political party I belong to is the entire body politic of the United States of America and our Constitution that I support without bias which neither states or implies any allegiance with any other socalled organized political party.

... literally. That was incredibly powerful. Please post whatever response you get here. And, in case you do not get a response, please let us know that, too! THANKS!!!

"NO SUPPORT FOR IMPEACHMENT FROM YOU, NO VOTE FOR YOU."

All 435 congressional seats are up for grabs in the coming election.

The only chance we have to bring accountability for these Bushco traitors is to make our reps understand that they will no longer have their job if they refuse to support impeachment proceedings. They don't need to see the messages. They just need to know from their staffers that if they don't start actually honoring their oath, they'll be looking for a new gig. This can only be accomplished with a relentless swamping of their phones, email and fax machines with demands for accountability for the Bush administration.

If your rep refuses to act on impeachment, DO NOT GIVE HIM OR HER YOUR VOTE. Don't try to rationalize by saying things like "Well, he's done some good things, impeachment is only one issue, maye I should just go ahead and vote for him..."

NO.

DO NOT FALL INTO THAT TRAP. IT'S EXACTLY WHAT THEY WANT.

Especially Conyers. He's resting lazily on his 40 years of experience, playing disgusting partisan politics while the Constitution he has sworn 21 times to support and defend burns. The voters of Michigan's 14th district, where Conyers serves, have an opportunity to send perhaps the biggest message of this election, by sending him packing if he refuses to initiate impeachment against Bush and Cheney.

It doesn't matter how long he has served or what he's accomplished. He's throwing it all away by refusing to even try to hold Bush and Cheney accountable.

UNFILTERED VIDEO COMMENTARY.

DEMAND IMPEACHMENT HEARINGS NOW:
johnconyersjr@gmail.com / john.conyers@mail.house.gov
Conyers phone: 202-225-5126 / Conyers fax: 202-225-0072

Excellent points, Johm. There was a time when I worried lest my Rep.'s office would get tired of hearing from me. That concern went flying out the window when I heard Ms. Pelosi refer to impeachment as "a distraction." Huh??? A "distraction" from WHAT? From the Constitution? From the rule of law? From their oaths of office? From building a campaign war chest? Poor Thomas Jefferson must be spinning in his grave!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

CHOOSE LANGUAGE

Support This Site

Donate.

Get free books and gear when you become a supporter.

 

Sponsors:

Speaking Truth to Empire

***

Families United

***

Ray McGovern

***

Financial supporters of this site can choose to be listed here.

 

Ads:

Find the perfect Purple Bridesmaid Dresses for your bridesmaids from Queeniebridesmaid.co.uk

 

*****

 

Ca-Dress Long Prom Dresses Canada
Ca Dress Long Prom Dresses on Ca-Dress.com

Buy Books

Get Gear

The log-in box below is only for bloggers. Nobody else will be able to log in because we have not figured out how to stop voluminous spam ruining the site. If you would like us to have the resources to figure that out please donate. If you would like to receive occasional emails please sign up. If you would like to be a blogger here please send your resume.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.