You are herecontent / The anti-war phonies

The anti-war phonies

By JOHN BRUHNS, Philadelphia Daily News

[Bruhns is the former legislative director for Americans Against Escalation in Iraq.]

I CAME HOME from Iraq in February 2004 and since then have fought tooth and nail for an end to the war.

I did so because I believe the war is immoral and illegal. I aligned myself with some high- profile lobbying organizations who I believed would have the most significant impact on ending the war. In doing so, I detached myself from the people of this country who are honestly committed to ending the war.

I traded my convictions for "special interest" groups who sometimes seem to be in place simply to smear those who disagree with their political agenda. But the agenda is not anti-war. The war is used by these organizations as ammunition against political foes - primarily Republicans. They are the enemy despite the fact that many Democrats vote the same way.

It was very hard for me to go "off the reservation." I didn't want to face the fact that these anti-war groups had other aims.

We watched as legislation that had no substantial impact on ending the war was debated. There ARE anti-war resolutions still floating out there that call for a real end to the war, but the groups I worked for wouldn't spend one dime to promote legislation considered out of the mainstream of the Democratic Party.

Any genuine anti-war message was filtered through media consultants who provide politically correct "talking points" to veterans for them to carry out a phony message that is beneficial to the campaign.

We threatened Republicans with "political extinction" if they didn't change their votes on Iraq. It was a partisan tactic that got us nowhere fast.

When I worked with these organizations, I did nothing to actually stop the war. I only put on a good show that would catch the attention of the media. We focused on America's desire for entertainment rather than the core issue of ending the war.

Our troops are still being killed on a daily basis and the main agenda of these well-financed anti-war groups, I think, is nothing short of the prolonged character assassination of all those who disagree with their message. In my eyes, it's just as bad as those who fight for a continuation of the war, and I'm no longer able to distinguish between the two sides.

I was not honest when I walked away and pursued the "lone wolf" route. Instead I painted a rosy picture of my departure in order to preserve my credibility and longevity within the establishment. This confession is the only way to restore my integrity. So I can go on to continue to fight against the war in Iraq with a clear conscience.

I didn't commit eight years of honorable military service to this country to be an indirect proxy of one political party. I saw the damage done to our country for most of the last seven years with the Republicans in control of the executive, legislative and judicial branches. There was no political balance whatsoever to keep our democracy pure. That's why we are so divided as a nation, and I'm not about to fight for the same partisan domination for the Democrats - even though that is my party affiliation.

THE Democrats promised they would bring change if given a majority in Congress. It didn't happen, and I'm not going to be fooled again. There are many courageous Democrats who vote to end the war in Iraq. But there are many who do not.

Republicans in Congress, for the most part, would follow George W. Bush to the gates of hell. And because of their unity, they are able to keep prevailing despite being in the minority of both houses of Congress.

If any candidate wants my vote, they first and foremost need to convince me that they will end the war in Iraq. *

John Bruhns is a writer and anti-war activist in the Philadelphia area.


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

They did talk a good game and did get support from my community until they threatened to call the media off from the town hall meeting we invited Senator John Warner to this past fall. We were NOT to bring up impeachment in any way shape or form. We suspect that the media was called off, and have been unable to get the video of the town hall which shows a majority for impeachment. Sen. Warner did not show, but the panelists, vetted by AAEI did appear to support impeachment on the whole, especially by the fathers of Iraq vets.

Thanks for your letter, John. It means a lot to me and probably a bunch of others. I really respect your coming out with this article.

We did the same thing at a Town Hall meeting with Congressman Tom Davis. I was instructed by the campaign leadership two hours prior to the start of the Town Hall to moderate and not let the audience ask any questions. Our campaign members took hand written questions, screened them, picked out which questions were appropriate or pc for the campaign's interests, and then handed them to me to ask Congressman Davis. You can see for yourself on C-SPAN. The campaign leadership instructed us to avoid most organizations of the anti-war movement who were considered too far left or "radical" according to the campaign, but at the same time we would hand out our signs for the members of those groups to carry in public, we would video tape it and take pictures to put on display as if we did all the work. But we would not dare stand in public with them in solidarity. All of those people were used. I was part of it and that is why I wrote this confession.

Thank you for your kind words.

John Bruhns

John Bruhns had nothing to do with VA actions. Just wanted folks to know the AAEI reference.

Thank you for this clear-headed wake-up call.

We would all do well do heed it and work harder to find ways to directly engage our uncommitted fellow citizens as well as our determined adversaries in respectful debate on the real issues, instead of wasting our time and resources supporting name-calling and political posturing while the war, occupation, death and destruction continue unchecked.

Perhaps you were trying to put the past behind you, but it surprised me not to see you mention any return to your erstwhile brothers (and sisters)-in-arms - the other veterans - who (at least, in my every experience with them) are very much of like mind with yourself. You Iraq veterans, in particular, are by far the most authoritative and credible of all Americans to speak to these causes today.



We will back you 110%.

Semper Fi,

-Matty in Florida

John-don't throw the bath water out with the baby. There are a lot of well meaning people(a lot of them vets)inside the anti-war groups. To keep their power to a minimum,the "bad guys"infiltrate them with leadership that will more often than not,neutralize their efforts. This has been going on since time immortal. Don't lose faith. Good will triumph over evil in the end. Just doesn't seem like it today. I'm a Viet Nam veteran. When I got home,I just wanted to be done with the whole mess. Then,when GWI started in '91,I began to wonder what was going on. I began to read "real"history(as opposed to published) There are more good people in this country than bad. But the bad guys don't want you to know that. Keep the faith. Robert

I had to cry foul when I saw "pro-choice" agenda piggy-back our peace activism meetings and anti-war rallies .

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.


Support This Site


Get free books and gear when you become a supporter.



Speaking Truth to Empire


Families United


Ray McGovern


Julie Varughese


Financial supporters of this site can choose to be listed here.



Ca-Dress Long Prom Dresses Canada
Ca Dress Long Prom Dresses on

Buy Books

Get Gear

The log-in box below is only for bloggers. Nobody else will be able to log in because we have not figured out how to stop voluminous spam ruining the site. If you would like us to have the resources to figure that out please donate. If you would like to receive occasional emails please sign up. If you would like to be a blogger here please send your resume.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.