You are herecontent / The Acoustics of a Ditch Empowers Americans to Question the War

The Acoustics of a Ditch Empowers Americans to Question the War

By Kevin B. Zeese

On August 6, just after the Veterans for Peace conference in Dallas, Cindy Sheehan and a handful of veterans camped out in a ditch alongside of a road outside of President Bush's ranch in Crawford, TX. They came unprepared in an unplanned protest – their only light was a flashlight – their only place to go to the bathroom was a bucket. They slept in ant-filled ditches in one hundred degree heat and when it rained their tents and sleeping bags got soaked. Their simple request to the president – meet with us to explain the reason for the Iraq war.

When we visited her 21 days later there were approximately 3,500 people joining her vigil and 1,000 pro-war demonstrators trying to counter her. Her camp had been moved next to the entrance of the president's ranch – thanks to a neighbor who believes in free speech under a tent large enough for 2,000 people. Finally, a much-needed conversation was taking place in America: Should the U.S. have invaded in Iraq? Should we stay in Iraq? How does the United States end the Iraq occupation responsibly and get our troops home quickly?

Nancy Lessin of Military Families Speak Out described the cascading response to Sheehan as the "acoustics of a ditch." The whole nation – indeed much of the world – has now heard of Sheehan. More and more are joining her asking – what is the noble cause for which Casey Sheehan and nearly 1,900 other American soldiers and over one hundred thousand Iraqis have died?

Even though President Bush has refused to meet with Sheehan he has found it necessary to create events to respond to her. Speaking to friendly audiences – the National Guard in Idaho and the Veterans of Foreign Wars in Utah – he broke White House policy and mentioned the total number of soldiers who have died. For years, antiwar advocates have tried to get him to acknowledge the high number of soldiers killed, complained about his undercount of deaths and those seriously injured in action, and watched in sadness as he prevented photos of caskets, and as the DoD brought the injured to the Walter Reed Medical Center in the middle of the night so the public could not see them.

But Sheehan forced him to acknowledge the deaths. Sadly, the president used the soldiers to support his war. He is running out of reasons for the war – there were no weapons of mass destruction, there was no connection between Saddam and bin Laden or al Qaeda, we're not bringing stability to Iraq – in fact, as Senator Hagel (R-NE) says, we're destabilizing the region. And, the invasion of Iraq is not making us safer as reports of the CIA and State Department have found the U.S. occupation is turning Iraq into a magnet and training ground for terrorists. The vaulted democracy the president has repeatedly mentioned turns out to be an Islamic Republic that gives Muslim clerics say in defining the law. And, creates a weak and poor Sunni region that will be a hotbed for unrest and further instability. The Constitution provides very weak protections for women, free speech and free press. So, how does the president use the soldiers who've died, he says: "We owe them something. We will finish the task that they gave their lives for."

When I met with Cindy Sheehan at Camp Casey she lamented "now he wants more of our kids to die because he's already killed so many in a war which has no justification." We can't justify more people dying because others have died in a war that was never justified. Every death in an unjustified war only compounds the mistake.

Camp Casey has started a national conversation. In Crawford, we heard the voices that America will hear and they are powerfully persuasive. A woman who lost her son in Iraq – afraid to speak out until Camp Casey – now she is empowered and will be silent no longer. How many hundreds or thousands are like her? An Iraq war veteran who told how when he was 17 he took an oath to defend and protect the United States and in his anti-war advocacy says "I am still defending the country today – from enemies within. We're all patriots here today." Another voice, a Latino who lost his nephew in Iraq who focused on the class realities of the war, what some have described as an "economic draft" and he described as "the false nobleman of today declaring a false noble cause fought by the poor who have no choices for the wealthiest to get wealthier." Sheehan, who has faced personal attacks and false barbs, provides the backbone of the Camp Casey Movement, proclaiming: "smear away because we aren't going away."

Of course, not all people who have lost family members in Iraq share the views of Sheehan and her supporters. But even here the approach is one of understanding and love. These activists know the pain and anguish of losing a relative in combat. They know that that pain is more difficult if their loved one died for no good reason. And, they recognize that many in the military come from families with generations of service. These are people who do not easily admit that the president of the United States would lie to send Americans to war. In time, these difficult realities will be faced. So the debate is joined and the American public will hear all sides – already support for the president is dropping.

While Democrats may be gleeful that Cindy has focused her attention on the President, they should realize that she also holds Democrats who support the war responsible. Ending the Iraq occupation and bringing our troops home transcends political parties. The Democrats, who are dropping in the polls as rapidly as President Bush, should be forewarned – they to will also be asked the question: "What is the noble cause for which our sons and daughters are dying?" If they fail to answer or answer in support of the war they too will feel the wrath of voters in November 2006.

Sheehan believes the Camp Casey Movement will end the Iraq War. Her stand has awoken the conscience of a nation that wants to return to being perceived as a moral leader in the world. The debate she has started will not be silenced.


Kevin Zeese [send him mail] Director of Democracy Rising visited Camp Casey in Crawford, TX on August 27. You can comment on this article by visiting the blog.


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Hey Cindy-

Why don't you ask why millions of babies have been murdered in America??? Any, why doesn't the mainstream news publish a daily body count for abortions? In America alone, hundreds of thousands of babies die (are murdered) each year. For what???

Check the abortion statistics reported by the CDC.

The noble cause you request is found in the constitution. It is the right to have privacy within ones own person.

... those who call themselves pro-life how they can support the killing of tens of thousands, including many children, in the name of "freedom and democracy". Do children become "fair game" after they leave the womb? Or does "pro-life" apply only to American fetuses?

How can those who oppose the war in Iraq, support the War Against the Unborn? The partial-birth abortion is a particularly cruel and gruesome "procedure." But, hey, I guess liberals see nothing wrong with driving a steel rod through the skull and brain of a living, breathing baby.

Who are you and what is your point?

If you are one of those disgusting religious one issue morons who vote repugnant/repulsive because they have brainwashed you into believing they are pro-life, you need only look at what these "Christians" are doing in Iraq.

Now, just to rile you up a little, let me tell you this. What a woman wants to do with her own reproductive health issues is none of your or the government's GOD DAMNED BUSINESS! CAPPICE? End of story.

By the way, it is also not any of the business of the Catholic Church! That is coming from a Catholic but I am also an attorney who respects the separation of church and state. In your mind I'm sure I'm going to hell. You know what, America is hell anyway thank to people like you and Bush!

Shameless, irrelevant, and ridiculous rhetoric is what comes to my mind when I hear Cindy Sheehan speak.

You could try not name calling, not spewing insults and not ASSuming I'm religious, or a Christian, or that I believe abortion should be outlawed. Actually, I'm not religous, and I believe abortion should not be outlawed, with the possible exception of partial-birth abortions (unless medically necessary). Many conservatives feel the same way.

For days, Cindy Sheehan has been asking why did her son die, and has been calling the supporters of the Iraq war "pro-killing." The pro-killing accusation just hit a nerve with me. It's so patently hypocritical for any liberal to accuse anyone of being pro-killing, when liberals support abortion and the killing of millions of unborn babies, for any reason. You can't candy coat abortion. Unless it's medically necessary, it's killing.

P.s. I just threw in the rhetoric because liberals like rhetoric so much. And, I've enjoyed hearing your point of view.

My views on abortion have absolutely nothing to do with the main topic here and, since you didn't answer my question about that, I see no reason to answer your assumptions.

I only support war, and the unfortunate killing, to the extent that war brings peace, and freedom. I would much prefer to support diplomacy, but I see no way to negotiate with terrorists.

NO connection, other than the powers-that-be becoming opposed to abortion when they decided they need more of poor people's babies to grow up & be their under-class soldiers to do the fighting of their power wars...They tied it up with 'religion' who bit big time, and the rest is history. They restrict the lives of poor women to bear more soldiers for their causes...Rich women have always had access to abortion to cover up their mistakes with rich men...

This nameless and shameless as well as irrelevant attack upon Mrs. Sheehan is yet another right wing ploy of desparation. Until this last day of the protest, the focus has been the Iraq war. Suddenly someone comes forth with this ridiculous rhetoric connecting Mrs. Sheehan with abortions. For once I guess I can understand why someone would not want to attach their name to such a disgusting post.

The right continues to show its true colors. Add this to the "chickenhawks" on the video from last weekend, that "brave" pick-up truck driver that destroyed the crosses with a pipe and chain and that neighbor who shot the gun "practicing" for dove season (and isn't it appropriate that this moron was shooting doves, the symbol of peace?). You right wingers really do yourselves and your President proud.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.


Support This Site


Get free books and gear when you become a supporter.



Speaking Truth to Empire


Families United


Ray McGovern


Julie Varughese


Financial supporters of this site can choose to be listed here.



Ca-Dress Long Prom Dresses Canada
Ca Dress Long Prom Dresses on

Buy Books

Get Gear

The log-in box below is only for bloggers. Nobody else will be able to log in because we have not figured out how to stop voluminous spam ruining the site. If you would like us to have the resources to figure that out please donate. If you would like to receive occasional emails please sign up. If you would like to be a blogger here please send your resume.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.