You are herecontent / Give Sheehan credit for reviving war debate

Give Sheehan credit for reviving war debate


By Bob Ray Sanders
Fort Worth Star-Telegram Staff Writer

Last week's column about Cindy Sheehan's protest near President Bush's ranch in Crawford generated so much reaction that I could not respond to all of you personally.

After directly replying to more than 50 e-mail messages, I finally had to create a "form letter" explaining my dilemma and promising to print some of your comments in a future column, which I will do Friday. My apologies to those of you who received that sincere but canned response.

The reaction was about evenly divided between people who support Sheehan, who lost her 24-year-old son in Iraq last year, and those who despise her for what she is doing and saying. A few people said they felt sorry for Sheehan but thought she was misguided to bring her complaint to the president's "doorstep" and demand a meeting with him.

More than anything, the flood of phone and e-mail messages proved my point that there is now a very serious debate in this country about a war many of us believe should never have been fought. It is a vociferous, passionate dialogue, one that we should have had before Bush decided to attack Iraq and send thousands of American troops there.

Sheehan gets credit for bringing the debate to the forefront and for energizing a heretofore quiescent anti-war movement. If for nothing else, she deserves thanks for that.

Yes, I know many of you reject that idea, and I'll let you have your say later.

But a democratic society that is afraid of public debate on an issue as grave as war is not a healthy society. I was beginning to worry that we had lost one of our most important democratic values: the right to disagree, even with the highest of powers.

I find it curious that many who chastise Sheehan for reportedly having called the president names resort to the same thing in referring to this grieving mother. Some of my correspondents went so far as to question her loyalty to our country and her dead son, suggesting that she dishonors both with her demonstration.

Although Bush won't grant Sheehan's request for a meeting, he has been forced to address the issue somewhat more directly in recent days.

In a speech this week, Bush mentioned for the first time the exact number of Americans who have died in Iraq and Afghanistan. His message has been that we honor them by staying the course, not by cutting and running.

Others would say, of course, that we show our respect for the servicemen and servicewomen by bringing them home as soon as possible.

Regardless of where you stand on the war or how you think this country should proceed in this conflict, you have the right to say exactly what is on your mind. And you ought to be able to say it without being called a traitor or un-American.

As I predicted, those who vilify Sheehan for her message only embolden those who agree with her. Even though she's had to leave her roadside post in Crawford temporarily to care for her ailing mother, the movement she's helped start is holding fast and getting stronger.

The president, as he has tried to do this week, will have to reckon with the growing discontent over the war.

More and more, he will be obliged to address it, and at some point he will likely realize that tired slogans and photo ops -- such as riding a bike with Lance Armstrong down on the ranch -- will not drown out the voices of protest.

The movement is very much alive. It is finally awake. And it is not likely to go back to sleep soon.

On Friday I will remain silent and turn over this space to readers.

___________

Bob Ray Sanders' column appears Sundays, Wednesdays and Fridays. (817) 390-7775 bobray@star-telegram.com

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

How ironic that a nation born in righteous protest and revolution against corrupt rulers should in just a bit over 200 years become so estranged from it's founders that righteous protest against today's corrupt leaders, has become an object of ridicule and villification? Who are these people calling themselves Americans who can so readily excuse the fact that the entire Iraq war is based upon deliberate lies by the Bush team, yet castigate Cindy Sheehan for exercising her civic duty to demand that the President who lied to get us into this foolish campaign, be held accountable for his crimes? Protest against the hopeless war in Iraq, is about much more than the war. It is literally about the destiny of this nation. Will we continue our lemming-like slide into a real-life Orwellian nightmare, or will we reassert our nation's founding ideals and fight for a return to respect for truth, and constitutional government?

Many Americans have been divided and brainwashed by the clever political indoctrination so prevelent in the mainstream media. These people don't think, have little use for facts, and don't want to know the truth. They are comfortable being used as pawns of a totalitarian cabal. For years the voices of these zombie-like ideologues, and their media manipulators, have been heard ad nauseum. Cindy Sheehan represents the powerful voice of Americans still loyal to the Constitution and individual thought. It is high time that our voices be heard! Thinking individuals have no problem seeing that the Iraq war is based upon deliberate lies by W. Bush, his cabinet, and the mainstream media. They have been so effective in dividing the nation with Orwellian "doublethink", that not supporting their corrupt leadership and criminal war, is labeled "unpatriotic"! The amazing thing is, that people are actually buying this! In George Orwell's novel 1984, lies became the "truth" and the truth became "lies". The mainstream media has the power to make this so, and Bush certainly understands this when repeating his drone-like mantras: "Stay the course", "Complete the mission". This subterfuge makes the whole idea of "Staying the course" or "Supporting the President" utterly ridiculous in light of the facts. The Iraq war is a case of criminal intent to engage U.S. forces in a war of conquest for personal and political gain. Nothing more nothing less. We must now get on with the business of stopping this unwinnable war, and our nation's mindless march to an Orwellian future. A future where the very act of individual thinking and Constitutional government, shall perish from these United States!

How ironic that a nation born in righteous protest and revolution against corrupt rulers should in just a bit over 200 years become so estranged from it's founders that righteous protest against today's corrupt leaders, has become an object of ridicule and villification? Who are these people calling themselves Americans who can so readily excuse the fact that the entire Iraq war is based upon deliberate lies by the Bush team, yet castigate Cindy Sheehan for exercising her civic duty to demand that the President who lied to get us into this foolish campaign, be held accountable for his crimes? Protest against the hopeless war in Iraq, is about much more than the war. It is literally about the destiny of this nation. Will we continue our lemming-like slide into a real-life Orwellian nightmare, or will we reassert our nation's founding ideals and fight for a return to respect for truth, and constitutional government?

Many Americans have been divided and brainwashed by the clever political indoctrination so prevelent in the mainstream media. These people don't think, have little use for facts, and don't want to know the truth. They are comfortable being used as pawns of a totalitarian cabal. For years the voices of these zombie-like ideologues, and their media manipulators, have been heard ad nauseum. Cindy Sheehan represents the powerful voice of Americans still loyal to the Constitution and individual thought. It is high time that our voices be heard! Thinking individuals have no problem seeing that the Iraq war is based upon deliberate lies by W. Bush, his cabinet, and the mainstream media. They have been so effective in dividing the nation with Orwellian "doublethink", that not supporting their corrupt leadership and criminal war, is labeled "unpatriotic"! The amazing thing is, that people are actually buying this! In George Orwell's novel 1984, lies became the "truth" and the truth became "lies". The mainstream media has the power to make this so, and Bush certainly understands this when repeating his drone-like mantras: "Stay the course", "Complete the mission". This subterfuge makes the whole idea of "Staying the course" or "Supporting the President" utterly ridiculous in light of the facts. The Iraq war is a case of criminal intent to engage U.S. forces in a war of conquest for personal and political gain. Nothing more nothing less. We must now get on with the business of stopping this unwinnable war, and our nation's mindless march to an Orwellian future. A future where the very act of individual thinking and Constitutional government, shall perish from these United States!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Support WarIsACrime



Donate.








Tweet your Congress critters here.


Advertise on this site!




Facebook      Twitter





Our Stores:























Movie Memorabilia.



The log-in box below is only for bloggers. Nobody else will be able to log in because we have not figured out how to stop voluminous spam ruining the site. If you would like us to have the resources to figure that out please donate. If you would like to receive occasional emails please sign up. If you would like to be a blogger here please send your resume.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.