You are herecontent / Mother's Protest Puts Pressure on Democrats

Mother's Protest Puts Pressure on Democrats

By Ronald Brownstein, Los Angeles Times Staff Writer

WASHINGTON -- The high-profile vigil near President Bush's Texas ranch by Cindy Sheehan, the mother of a soldier killed in Iraq last year, could scramble the politics of the war as much for her allies as for the target of her protest.

The most immediate effect may be to increase the pressure on liberal activist groups and Democrats -- who have focused mostly this year on other issues -- to challenge Bush more persistently and forcefully on the war.

"It has gotten people back in the fight," said Eli Pariser, executive director of the political action committee associated with the liberal "What we're seeing is a lot of people ... recommitting themselves."

Anti-war activists, who have been largely inactive since the 2004 election, are organizing around Sheehan's protest: Wednesday, the MoveOn PAC and two other liberal groups will sponsor more than 1,000 candlelight vigils around the United States to support her.

For Bush, a reinvigorated protest movement presents obvious dangers as he struggles to bolster flagging public support for the U.S. mission in Iraq. But such a challenge could present opportunities for the White House as well.

If a revived anti-war movement promotes alternative policies that the public resists -- such as the immediate withdrawal of all American troops that Sheehan favors -- Bush could garner support for his course, some analysts say.

"If it's a message that he is able to portray . . . as a fringe opposition group, I think he can use that as a foil," said Christopher Gelpi, a Duke University political scientist who studies public opinion during wartime. "On the other hand, if the movement's (message) is picked up by other politicians or prominent opinion leaders, that could be very damaging to him."

The neighbor who fired a shotgun over Sheehan's roadside camp earlier this week and the pickup truck driver who on Monday night barreled through wooden crosses that her supporters had erected underscored another risk for anti-war activists: the possibility of a backlash. As the Vietnam era demonstrated, protests even against an unpopular war can spark resentment and charges of undermining the troops.

"From the anti-war standpoint, there is some danger that it could be counterproductive," said John Mueller, an Ohio State University political scientist who also has written extensively on public opinion during war.

The attention that Sheehan has attracted by camping near Bush's ranch in Crawford while seeking a meeting with him is proof that politics abhors a vacuum.

Amid relentless violence in Iraq, public support for the war has sagged in many surveys to the lowest levels since the invasion in March 2003. Eight times this year, the Gallup Organization has asked whether "it was worth going to war in Iraq or not"; each time, at least half of those polled have said "no." Polls now routinely show public support for Bush's handling of the war stuck around 40 percent or below.

Yet despite rising public concern, the level of political debate has diminished since Bush and his allies relentlessly challenged the Democrats' toughness on national defense during the 2004 presidential election.

Some liberal Websites maintained a drumbeat of criticism, and a bipartisan group of House members -- led by Republican Walter Jones of North Carolina and Democrat Neil Abercrombie of Hawaii -- introduced legislation in June requiring Bush to begin withdrawing troops from Iraq by October 2006.

But until now, no individual or institution emerged as a rallying point for those disaffected by the war. Sheehan appears to be filling that void -- providing the visible presence that many on the left have sought.

The powerful response she has evoked appears to have convinced leading anti-war groups that there is now a constituency for a renewed protest effort. The surprisingly strong showing by Democrat Paul Hackett, an Iraq war veteran who criticized Bush's handling of the conflict, in an Ohio special congressional election earlier this month has encouraged the same conclusion.

"I think this is a turning point," said Tom Andrews, a onetime Maine congressman who is the national director of the anti-war coalition Win Without War.

Both Andrews and Pariser say they expect opponents to renew their efforts against the war. An initial step will come Wednesday with the meetings around the country to support Sheehan.

Over the longer term, both Andrews and Pariser say, their groups will focus on lobbying for the resolution from Jones and Abercrombie, which now has 45 co-sponsors -- far from the 218 votes needed for passage. That resolution would require Bush to develop a plan by year's end "for the withdrawal of all" American troops from Iraq; actual withdrawals would start by October 2006.

Andrews also said that he expected "increasingly active and increasingly vocal" public protests against the war in the coming months.

These developments could pressure Democrats, especially those considering the 2008 presidential election, to criticize the war more sharply.


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Tomorrow August 17, there are many Vigils all over, I just checked Southern California, Lots and lots of interest. Please Join.

For info per Zip Code see:

Looked at website and there now are more than 1400 vigils
scheduled nationwide...and it is growing by the minute...
God Bless You Cindy

Even if they don't fully support Sheehan's view they should at least LOUDLY condemn the Right Wing attacks.

The GOPhers were on the wrong side of Shiavo issue and they're on the wrong side of this issue. Its time for our leaders to STAND-UP.

It was okay for Terri to die but not okay for Casey to die!!! You're a hypocrite!!! And, a Democrat!!! See the connection Democrats are hypocrites!!!

and demand they support Representative Barbara Lee's resolution.

It's time to take action...Support Cindy... demand answers...Bush and company has lied to many times. To many American service men and women have died becasue of Bush's quest for oil.

Andrews also said that he expected "increasingly active and increasingly vocal" public protests against the war in the coming months.

They aint seen nothing yet!!!

Unfortunately, these poor jounalists have never read the Downing Street Minutes, which prove that Bush LIED to start a war that has cost thousands of lives. You might call him a mass murderer. Should we have to have a mass murderer as our leader?

Don't meet with Cindy.
You had your chance.
Now it is time to resign.

don't meet with Cindy
she already got her chance
you're doing a better job than any democrat could


If you can't make one of the vigils tonight how about putting a candle on your front steps. Imagine all the candles...what a powerful message!

I'll be around with my hose. Lighting candles for the fallen is one thing... send the distraught mother to Dr. Phil. Why is anyone holding candlelight vigils for an anti-American?

could pressure Democrats, especially those considering the 2008 election, to criticize the war more sharply." Well, what are they waiting for? I'm listening, but what I'm hearing is Democrats like Biden and Hillary trying to get on the other side of the Republicans - trying to outHawk them. I see that Edwards' wife posted something here for Cindy, but where is HIS voice? What's HE waiting for?

I'm sick of thses cautiouscratic phonies. I hope Ralph Nader runs again so I can have somebody real to vote for.
R Ap

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.


Support This Site


Get free books and gear when you become a supporter.



Speaking Truth to Empire


Families United


Ray McGovern


Julie Varughese


Financial supporters of this site can choose to be listed here.



Ca-Dress Long Prom Dresses Canada
Ca Dress Long Prom Dresses on

Buy Books

Get Gear

The log-in box below is only for bloggers. Nobody else will be able to log in because we have not figured out how to stop voluminous spam ruining the site. If you would like us to have the resources to figure that out please donate. If you would like to receive occasional emails please sign up. If you would like to be a blogger here please send your resume.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.