You are herecontent / Impeach Cheney First

Impeach Cheney First

By David Swanson

We should impeach Vice President Dick Cheney first, and President George Bush immediately thereafter. This idea is not original with me. It's been seen on bumper stickers for quite some time. My attention has been called to it by the fact that Congresswoman and Judiciary Committee Member Maxine Waters is talking about it. See below.

I'm persuaded of thevalue of this approach for several reasons. Among activists who very much want impeachment, one can hear a long list of fears and concerns about how things might go wrong, how impeachment could help Republicans who come around and back it, how impeachment could take energy away from elections, etc. But by far the most common of the nonsensical fears one hears is this one: "Impeaching Bush would give us Cheney, who is worse."

By proposing to impeach Cheney first, we eliminate this fear.

I cannot conceive of a serious investigation, with subpoena power, of either Bush or Cheney that would not incriminate the other as well. If I'm right about this, then the whole debate over which of these two criminals to impeach first, in one sense, doesn't mean much. But for purposes of organizing activists today it means everything. We need as many people as possible – including those terrified by Cheney – to push for an impeachment investigation. This campaign, and an investigation itself, should we get one, serve educational and political purposes. They further discredit Bush and Cheney while helping to build an opposition.

Our choices are not between impeachment and elections but between both and neither. Polls suggest it will be very difficult to win elections without demanding impeachment.

After an investigation, we will have to fight for impeachment, and after that for conviction and removal from office by the Senate, and after that for criminal indictments. While millions of Americans who favor impeachment have announced to each other that this goal is impossible or extremely unlikely to be achieved, almost every single one of them has implicitly determined that conviction in the Senate (which has never been achieved with a president in U.S. history) is a guaranteed lock. Thus "impeachment" is equated with "removal from office." We should bear in mind that Clinton was impeached but not removed from office. We very much need to remove Bush and Cheney from office, but it's remarkable how quickly we jump ahead to that stage when searching for reasons to fear and doubt ourselves.

If we were to impeach Bush and remove him from office and somehow not manage to do the same to Cheney, there would be a number of advantages to this. The man who is running much of the government backstage would be thrust up front. His 18 percent approval rating makes Bush's 32 percent look stellar. A President Cheney would be a lame duck and a walking advertisement against the Republican party and its Democratic allies.

If, somehow, we were to remove Cheney from office and leave Bush untouched, there would be disadvantages. Bush would (if Congress caved in, as it almost always does) be able to install as Vice President someone capable of running for the top job in 2008.

Nonetheless, I am persuaded that we should go after Cheney first. Again, he is incredibly unpopular. Very few Republicans in Congress are going to be willing to defend him. This will split the White House and the Republican Party and (if this can ever be done) unite the Democrats behind an aggressive and popular position. This would be a step toward a strong push in Congress for the impeachment of Bush as well. Aiming for the low hanging fruit first is just good organizing.

Currently 36 Congress Members (two of them just added this week) support Congressman Conyers' bill to create an investigation into grounds for impeachment of Bush (actually of any unnamed individuals in the Bush Administration). I suspect that specifically and exclusively targeting Cheney could add significantly to that number right away.

While it is the duty of U.S. citizens to demand the impeachment of criminal office holders, regardless of any predictions of success, it makes sense to begin from the angle most likely to succeed. More important than which individual ends up briefly or for years afterwards occupying the Oval Office is that he or she be aware that we can hold them accountable, that they be compelled to fear us, rather than we continuing to fear them.

The situation in Congress is as follows. Congressman John Conyers has taken the lead on the matter of impeachment and is not at this time prepared to move beyond his resolution for an investigation. Many other members are not leaders and will only sign onto someone else's initiative. Of those who are leaders, most defer to Conyers and are reluctant to step ahead of him, even as their constituents demand it ever more insistently. But introducing articles of impeachment against Cheney, and not Bush, is something that Conyers' office has suggested he would not oppose.

The idea arose several weeks back when Congresswoman Waters' proposed it at a meeting of several Congress Members, staff, and activists, which I attended. She went public with the idea this past Saturday at a forum in Sacramento held by the California Democratic Party Progressive Caucus. Nearly 1,000 rowdy, enthusiastic party members packed a large hall to capacity to hear Waters and others discuss impeachment. According to Bob Fertik, who spoke on the panel and wrote an account of it afterwards:

"…the next question [was] why Congressional Democrats have refused to introduce Articles of Impeachment. Luckily Rep. Maxine Waters was on the panel, and she described discussions we had earlier this year, which led her to propose impeaching Cheney first. That discussion was sidetracked when Sen. Russ Feingold introduced his Censure Resolution, but the refusal of most Senate Democrats to back Feingold appears to have convinced Waters to move ahead with her idea. And of course we will support Waters 1000% if she does."

1000 percent? Is that all? She'll be a national hero. No. Scratch that. She'll be an international hero. We'll need to add a Maxine Waters Day to our calendars, celebrating the day on which she placed the first stone in the edifice of a rebuilt democracy by introducing articles of impeachment against Richard Cheney.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

1) for whatever reason, people fear accusing george. perhaps people hesitant to impeach bush (even though they agree that it should be done) would be less hesitant to impeach cheney

2) impeaching cheney would turn over all sorts of new rocks that have so far remained out of public awareness. the more that comes to light, the more people would open their eyes to george's crimes. Perhaps even things that the more informed populace, such as the people reading this web site, don't even know.

3) I don't know anything about prosecution, but the most successful ones (such as fitzgerald) seem to agree that it's best to go after the smaller fish first, then build up to the big guys. (actually, that would argue for impeaching GEORGE first, wouldn't it?!)


P.S.- people often reason that there was a BACKLASH against the ones who pushed for impeaching Clinton- That's because he was being impeached for CHEATING ON HIS WIFE- remember that after being impeached, clinton got a standing ovation in the U.N.- everybody knew that the charges were crap. the charges against george are SERIOUS.
also, the polling shows that the public never did support impeaching Clinton. not so with george.

Mr. Swanson. Just how many more times do we have to listen to this dribble. Bush? Cheney? What the hell difference does it make if no one is stepping up and doing it! How much longer does Maxine Waters need to wait before she submitts a petition for Articles of Impeachment? Everyone sure sounds like they know that there is evidence, proof that this is warranted. So why wait? This is just more lame talk while the murdering continues. Last week Barbara Lee held her meeting and AGAIN restated the obvious. Did anyone stand up and pledge to submit a petition NOW? NO THEY DID NOT. This hurry up and wait method is killing people every minute of every day. Stop supporting any currently elected member of the House of Representatives unless he/she stands up, demands impeachment and submits the petition. You are all making me sick while you intellectualize what a great idea this is. It is far past time for you and yours to stop supporting ANY member of the House of Representatives who clearly is more concerned with keeping their job than doing their job. I am certain this fear to act will make a great, long chapter in George Bush's memoirs. He won't have to write it. You, Maxine Waters and the rest of the ELECTED members of the House of Representatives already have.

Thomas Vacanti
3967 Cumberland Avenue
Los Angeles, CA 90027

I'd settle for either one of 'em doing a perp walk with Tony Snow left to explain it all away!

We don't need to be lumps of innactive clay while this is all happening. We can help initiate it by sending in an Impeachment Memorial. It's not an online petition. It has the same legal weight as a State passing a resolution, only YOU can do it YOURSELF.


With much due respect to Mr. Conyers, we don't need an investigation. We already have the evidence. We need a trial.

As far as impeaching Cheney first is concerned, don't we run the risk of a presidential pardon for the most heinous neocon of them all?

Is it not possible to bring impeachment charges against both simultaneously?

Call me crazy, but I say that unprecedented criminality in our government calls for unprecedented action to remove the criminals.

John Perry

Demand accountability.

Yes, this is a fantastic idea! Impeach Cheney, setting up the appointment of Condi as VP. Then either impeach Bush, leaving Condi as President, or just wait until 2008 when Condi can run on her own.

Since I'm a Republican, I really LIKE this idea. Gosh, it's like we don't even NEED Karl Rove and his secret machinations anymore.

... it's tough to read the expiration date from inside the mayo jar.

Good luck with that impeachment thing.

Impeach Bush yourself! That's right. This is much more than just a petition.

There's a little known and rarely used clause of the in the rules for
the House of Representatives which sets forth the various ways in
which a president can be impeached. Only the House Judiciary
Committee puts together the Articles of Impeachment, but before that
happens, someone has to initiate the process.

That's where we come in. One of the ways to get impeachment going is
for individual citizens like you and me to submit a memorial. has created a new memorial based on one which was
successful in impeaching a federal official in the past. You can find
it on their website as a PDF.

You can initiate the impeachment process yourself by downloading the
memorial, filling in the relevant information in the blanks (your
name, state, etc.), and sending it in.

More information on the precedent for submitting an impeachment
memorial, and the House Rules on this procedure, can also be found at
the above address.

If you have any doubts that Bush has committed crimes warranting
impeachment, read this page:

If you're concerned that impeachment might not be the best strategy
at this point, read the
bottom of this page:

It just takes a minute to save our democracy.


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.


Support This Site


Get free books and gear when you become a supporter.



Speaking Truth to Empire


Families United


Ray McGovern


Financial supporters of this site can choose to be listed here.



Find the perfect Purple Bridesmaid Dresses for your bridesmaids from




Ca-Dress Long Prom Dresses Canada
Ca Dress Long Prom Dresses on

Buy Books

Get Gear

The log-in box below is only for bloggers. Nobody else will be able to log in because we have not figured out how to stop voluminous spam ruining the site. If you would like us to have the resources to figure that out please donate. If you would like to receive occasional emails please sign up. If you would like to be a blogger here please send your resume.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.